Can drums beat depression?

  • August 1, 2011 | Alex

    I’ve always found hitting drums to be very therapeutic. So I’m not surprised to read that playing musical instruments can temporarily help tackle depression.

    A group of patients suffering from depression had music therapy alongside normal counselling. After three months the musical patients were less anxious and depressed than patients who just had standard counselling. However, after six months the researchers found that the difference disappeared.

    Scientists think that music may help patients express things that they can’t put into words.

  • Do you like this story?

    VN:F [1.9.4_1102]
    746 people liked this story
     
  • Poll

    What type of music makes you feel better?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...
Image of a drummer

Patients had 20 sessions with a trained music therapist, which involved activities such as drumming.

Image: Flickr/dougbutchy Enlarge
 

5 comments on 'Can drums beat depression?'

  1. Priya

    Priya

    August 2, 2011 at 17:24

    People often scoff at things like music therapy and art therapy so its interesting that serious scientific work is going into finding out if these approaches have an effect.

    I wonder whether some or all of the people in the study liked music anyway?

    • Reply
    • VA:F [1.9.4_1102]
      0 people liked this comment

    • suzy

      Suzy

      August 3, 2011 at 17:47

      Me too – I wonder if any of the people in the study were already musicians too…

      • Reply
      • VN:F [1.9.4_1102]
        0 people liked this comment

  2. Viv

    Viv

    August 4, 2011 at 13:22

    I guess it’s a positive stimulus and arguably something that improves quality of life somewhat.

    • Reply
    • VA:F [1.9.4_1102]
      0 people liked this comment

  3. alexf

    Alex

    August 4, 2011 at 14:28

    I’m not sure if they participants were musically inclined before they took part.

    Here’s an interesting quote from the lead scientist on the study: ‘‘We found that people often expressed their inner pressure and feelings by drumming or with the tones produced with a mallet instrument. Some people described their playing experience as cathartic.”

    • Reply
    • VN:F [1.9.4_1102]
      0 people liked this comment

  4. Peter

    Peter

    August 4, 2011 at 21:12

    Playing the bagpipes makes me happy, but it does not seem to do the same for some of my friends and colleagues

    • Reply
    • VA:F [1.9.4_1102]
      0 people liked this comment

Share your comment

  • Write as if you were talking to a friend (and maybe in front of your mother!).

    Keep it classy, keep it clean and keep your temper.

    Comments may be displayed in the gallery as well as on the website - check out our Community Guidelines for more info.